Supreme Court Upholds Inclusion of Royalty in Mineral Sale Value to Prevent Evasion

sketch of the Supreme Court of India
Case
KIRLOSKAR FERROUS INDUSTRIES LIMITED v. UNION OF INDIA (Supreme Court of India, 13-07-2026)
Law
Constitution of India, Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, Administrative Law.

Highlights of the Judgment:

  • Validity of including royalty, DMF, and NMET payments in "sale value" under Section 9 of the MMDR Act.
  • Application of the presumption of constitutionality to subordinate mineral concession rules.
  • The legal distinction between the "measure of a levy" and the "nature of a levy" in fiscal policy.
  • Use of regulatory loading on sale value as a valid mechanism to prevent price manipulation and tax evasion.
  • Article 14 discrimination analysis regarding different royalty computation methodologies for coal and iron ore.
  • Standard of judicial review for economic policies and the irrelevance of individual hardship in determining constitutional validity.